
The Supreme Court of Canada declared on April 12, 2024 that Canada dishonourably breached Treaty No. 7 by providing the Blood Tribe with a reserve 162.5 square miles smaller than promised. But it upheld the limitation defence that barred the Tribe's claim for land and compensation through the lawsuit.
The unanimous judgment in Shot Both Sides v. Canada, 2024 SCC 12 drew an important distinction between enforcing a treaty claim through coercive relief and obtaining a declaration that identifies the Crown's breach. The declaration did not order Canada to transfer land or pay damages. It established the legal foundation for further reconciliation efforts.
Justice Michelle O'Bonsawin, writing for seven judges, held that treaty rights were enforceable before their constitutional protection in 1982. Section 35 of the Constitution Act, 1982 therefore did not restart the clock for this claim.
A promise measured in square miles
The Blood Tribe, also known as the Kainai, is part of the Blackfoot Confederacy. Treaty No. 7, signed in 1877, promised reserve land calculated at one square mile for each family of five, with proportionate amounts for larger and smaller families.
The reserve was surveyed in 1882 at roughly 650 square miles. A second survey in 1883 moved its southern boundary north after officials identified an overlap with grazing leases granted to third parties. That reduced the reserve to 547.5 square miles.
The treaty entitlement was larger than either survey. The trial judge found that Canada underestimated the Tribe's membership and should have provided 710 square miles—a shortfall of 162.5 square miles. Those factual findings were not challenged on appeal, and Canada ultimately conceded the treaty breach.
Research conducted between 1969 and 1971 established the boundary changes and the population information needed to identify the shortfall. The Tribe sought negotiations in 1976, but the federal minister rejected its claims in 1978. It began the Federal Court action in January 1980.
The litigation included distinct claims. A broader territorial claim was dismissed on its merits, while a claim concerning the reduction from the 1882 survey was held out of time. The Supreme Court appeal concerned the treaty land entitlement claim; it did not reopen those other outcomes.
Why constitutional protection did not revive the lawsuit
The trial judge had accepted the treaty land entitlement claim despite finding that its underlying facts were discoverable in 1971 or shortly afterward. In his view, section 35 created a new cause of action in 1982, so the earlier limitation period had not barred the claim.
The Federal Court of Appeal rejected that reasoning. The Supreme Court agreed with the appeal court.
Treaty promises were legally binding when made, the Court held. A long line of decisions before 1982 recognized and enforced treaty obligations, including through declarations and monetary relief. They were not merely political promises dependent on the government's goodwill.
The Tribe argued that some earlier cases involved using treaties defensively rather than suing to enforce them. The Court rejected that distinction: either use demonstrated that a treaty had legal effect. It also rejected reliance on historical reasoning that denied treaties their binding character and reflected prejudices repudiated by later courts.
Section 35 gave existing Aboriginal and treaty rights constitutional protection against unilateral abrogation by legislation. It did not create the treaty rights themselves. Their existence and scope came from the treaty, and the common law already supplied a judicial remedy for breach.
That distinguished this case from a Charter equality claim considered in Ravndahl v. Saskatchewan, where the relevant legal right arose only when the Charter's equality provision took effect. The Blood Tribe's enforceable right had existed since Treaty No. 7 was made in 1877.
Alberta's applicable legislation imposed a six-year limitation period through a residual provision covering actions not otherwise specified. Federal law made that provincial rule applicable to this Federal Court proceeding. Because the Tribe did not challenge the finding that the claim was discoverable by 1971, its 1980 lawsuit came too late.
The Court expressly limited its ruling. The parties had not raised a constitutional challenge to the applicability or operation of the limitation legislation. The judges declined interveners' invitations to decide that broader issue. The decision therefore did not settle every constitutional question about limitation periods and Indigenous claims.
A declaration remained available
The limitation defence did not eliminate the Court's power to declare the Crown's breach. Claims for damages or other personal relief may be time-barred, while declarations concerning the constitutionality of Crown conduct remain available. Here, the dispute concerned a constitutionally protected treaty right and the honour of the Crown.
A declaration is an authoritative statement of legal rights or relationships without an accompanying enforcement order. It is discretionary, not automatic. The court must have jurisdiction, the dispute must be real, the claimant must have a genuine interest, the respondent must have an interest in opposing the declaration, and the declaration must have practical utility.
The Supreme Court found those conditions satisfied. Canada had failed to provide the promised land, and Crown representatives later falsely told the Tribe that its entitlement had been fulfilled. The Court described that conduct as deplorable. An authoritative declaration could clarify the rights and breach and guide reconciliation beyond the courtroom.
Canada's late concession did not make the dispute academic. It had resisted the Tribe's position through decades of contested litigation. Allowing that concession to prevent a declaration would elevate form over the substance of the dispute, the Court said.
The declaration confirmed three things: the Tribe was entitled to a 710-square-mile reserve; the reserve provided was 162.5 square miles smaller; and Canada dishonourably breached the treaty land entitlement provisions by providing only 547.5 square miles. The Tribe was also awarded its legal costs throughout the proceedings.
What the ruling left for resolution
The Court described declaratory relief as a step toward reconciliation, not its completion. Negotiations and other processes could address the breach beyond the time-barred court claim, but the judgment itself fixed no compensation and directed no land transfer.
A federal question-period note dated June 19, 2024 said Canada would continue working with the Blood Tribe to try to resolve the claim. The Supreme Court docket later recorded correspondence about settlement of litigation costs in April 2025. That entry concerned costs, not compensation for the land shortfall.
In a July 24, 2026 statement, the Blackfoot Confederacy reported that its leaders had met with the federal Crown-Indigenous Relations minister to discuss implementation and advancing negotiations on the claim. It also reported an Assembly of First Nations resolution calling for dedicated treaty-land negotiations. The statement described discussions and advocacy, not a concluded settlement, land transfer or payment.



