The Federal Court of Appeal has overturned duty relief for Medline Canada's surgical gloves, ruling that a surgeon holding a scalpel while wearing a glove does not make the glove part of, or attached to, the instrument for the tariff provision at issue.

In Canada (Attorney General) v. Medline Canada Corporation, 2026 FCA 74, the court allowed the federal government's appeal and declared the gloves ineligible for classification under tariff item 9977.00.00. It awarded appeal costs to the Attorney General and dismissed a separate, alternative judicial review application without costs.

Refund claim rested on the relationship with scalpels

Medline imported the gloves between November 2015 and March 2018. Their ordinary classification as surgical gloves of vulcanized rubber was undisputed. The company later sought refunds under Chapter 99 of the Customs Tariff, which provides relief from duties otherwise payable for specified goods.

The Canada Border Services Agency denied the refunds, and its president maintained that decision. The Canadian International Trade Tribunal reversed the result in January 2024 after hearing evidence from Medline's clinical and training director and a surgeon.

The provision covered articles for use in medical and surgical instruments. Its statutory definition required the articles to be worked or incorporated into, or attached to, the other goods. Everyone accepted that the gloves were not worked or incorporated into scalpels. The dispute concerned attachment.

The tribunal applied a two-part test requiring both a physical connection and a functional relationship. It found that the temporary glove-scalpel contact during surgery, improved grip and tactile feedback, and protection against infection satisfied that test.

A legal question, not a second weighing of evidence

Medline argued that the government's challenge fell outside the Customs Act's appeal right, which is limited to questions of law. Tariff classification commonly involves applying law to facts.

The appeal court nevertheless found a separable legal question: what the statutory language could mean when constant human intervention maintained the connection. The government's case challenged interpretation rather than asking the court to reweigh the evidence. That brought the appeal within its jurisdiction and required the court to decide the legal question for itself, without deferring to the tribunal.

The court also rejected Medline's objection that the government had introduced a new argument about an independent physical connection. The underlying issue had not changed. Even if the argument was differently expressed, Medline had notice and had answered it fully.

Use alongside an instrument was not enough

Justice René LeBlanc, writing for a unanimous panel, examined both authoritative language versions, the surrounding tariff provisions and Chapter 99's purpose. The English and French texts required more than holding two objects together. The French wording reinforced the need for the article to enter into the composition of the other goods through attachment.

Parliament also used different expressions elsewhere for goods used with other goods or by particular users. Treating gloves used alongside scalpels as articles used in them would erase those distinctions and expand the specific duty-relief provision.

The court found both branches of the tribunal's test unsatisfied. The gloves did not become physically integrated into scalpels, and their connection depended on the surgeon continuously holding them together. The gloves benefited the surgeon and reduced infection risks, but those benefits were not enhancements to the scalpel's own function.

The reasoning did not require every connection to be permanent or reject wireless connections as a category. The court distinguished connections maintained independently of constant user intervention from the hand-held relationship in this case.

Because only one classification outcome was legally available, the court substituted the decision rather than returning the matter to the tribunal. Its ruling concerned the specific gloves and tariff item, not whether surgical gloves are medically necessary or useful. The reasons did not quantify the disputed duties or the appeal costs.

The government's parallel judicial review application repeated the appeal arguments and was unnecessary once the statutory appeal properly resolved the dispute. The court cautioned that the availability of judicial review does not mean a duplicative application should be brought.