Pasqua First Nation’s surviving claims that Saskatchewan mishandled requests under a settlement agreement can proceed after the Federal Court of Appeal rejected the province’s attempt to have the entire action struck.

In Saskatchewan (Attorney General) v. Pasqua First Nation, 2026 FCA 83, a unanimous panel dismissed Saskatchewan’s appeal with costs on April 27. Justice David Stratas delivered the reasons from the bench.

The ruling preserves an opportunity to prove the remaining allegations. It does not establish that Saskatchewan breached the agreement, acted dishonestly or discriminated, and it does not order the province to sell any particular land or mineral rights.

The claim had already been narrowed

In March 2025, the Federal Court struck some parts of the claim but allowed others to continue. Saskatchewan argued on appeal that the whole claim should have been dismissed.

The appeal court found that the lower court had used the proper approach: read the pleading practically and as a whole, identify its essential character, and strike a claim for disclosing no reasonable cause of action only when failure is plain and obvious, assuming the pleaded facts are true.

That assumption is a feature of this preliminary motion, not a finding that the allegations have been proven. The court also found no palpable and overriding error in applying the legal principles.

Discretion to refuse a sale did not answer the conduct allegations

The surviving allegations concern Saskatchewan’s duties to give requests favourable consideration, act in good faith and perform the settlement agreement consistently with the honour of the Crown.

The appeal court identified an existing legal basis on which those claims could succeed. The agreement itself required favourable consideration. Contract law recognizes good faith and honest performance. Supreme Court authority also recognizes a higher standard of Crown conduct for agreements with Indigenous groups entered into because of their Indigenous difference and against a background of reconciliation.

Saskatchewan argued that courts could not rewrite the agreement. The appeal court accepted that principle, but said the agreement’s meaning remained a live issue in light of those obligations. The Federal Court was entitled to conclude that evidence was needed to resolve it.

Two provisions confirmed that Saskatchewan did not have to sell particular lands or minerals. That did not dispose of the allegation that the province fell short of the required standard in the process of deciding not to sell.

Evidence will matter at a later stage

The province relied on earlier decisions involving Muskoday, Witchekan Lake and George Gordon First Nations. The appeal court upheld the distinction drawn below: those were summary-judgment cases decided on evidence, not motions to strike in which the factual allegations were taken as true.

Saskatchewan also disputed an allegation that it exercised discretion under the Wildlife Habitat Protection Act discriminatorily. It invoked provisions of that legislation, regulations and the settlement agreement. Again, the court held that the preliminary pleading stage was not the place to resolve the factual dispute without evidence.

The panel expressly left open the possibility of summary judgment later, depending on the evidentiary record. For now, the remaining claims survived, while the portions already struck were not restored. The costs award in these appeal reasons did not specify an amount.