A business owner’s damages claim over the deactivation of her Instagram account could not proceed in the Federal Court because it was a private contractual dispute outside that court’s jurisdiction, the Federal Court of Appeal ruled.

But the appeal judges expressly declined to endorse the lower court’s reasoning about Meta’s contract terms requiring disputes to be heard in California.

In Gorenstein v. Meta Platforms, Inc., 2026 FCA 97, decided May 15, 2026, the court dismissed Tatiana Gorenstein’s appeal without a costs order. The result left the action stayed, but on a different basis from the Federal Court’s decision.

An Instagram account used for a resale business

Gorenstein owned a luxury-goods resale and consignment business that used Instagram for sales and promotion. She created the account in November 2016 and began buying advertisements from Meta shortly afterward.

Meta deactivated the account on May 11, 2024, alleging the sale or promotion of counterfeit goods. It reinstated the account ten days later and acknowledged that deactivation had been a mistake. Meta deactivated it again on May 29 for the same stated reason and reactivated it on October 2.

The appeal ruling did not find that Gorenstein sold counterfeit goods. It described Meta’s allegation as the reason given for the account restrictions.

Gorenstein sued for economic losses. Meta obtained a permanent stay of the action in the Federal Court, relying on a forum-selection clause: a contractual provision identifying where litigation must take place.

The Federal Court lacked jurisdiction over this claim

After hearing the appeal, the Federal Court of Appeal asked the parties for submissions on whether the Federal Court had statutory authority to decide the claim at all. Both sides agreed that it did not.

Justice Donald Rennie, writing for a unanimous panel, agreed. This claim was essentially a private contractual dispute with no link to a recognized source of Federal Court jurisdiction.

That conclusion was not a rule that the Federal Court can never interpret private contracts. The court routinely does so within areas of its jurisdiction, including intellectual property. The problem was the absence of such a jurisdictional connection in this case.

Meta’s forum clauses were not judicially endorsed

Although jurisdiction disposed of the appeal, the court explained why its decision should not be taken as approval of the lower court’s contractual analysis.

A party seeking to enforce a forum-selection clause must first establish that the clause is valid, clear and enforceable and applies to the claim. Only then does the burden shift to the plaintiff to establish strong reasons not to enforce it.

Three documents and two clauses were involved here. Instagram’s Terms of Use distinguished consumers, who could sue in a competent court in their country of residence, from other users subject to a California forum clause. Separate Ad Terms referred advertising disputes to a clause in the Commercial Terms, also designating California courts for commercial claims outside the United States.

The Federal Court had focused on whether Gorenstein was a consumer. The appeal court said that did not answer whether the clause met the requirements of clarity, validity and enforceability. The necessary findings had not been made.

The lower court also had not addressed her argument that the Terms of Use clause was unconscionable. Nor was it clear which of the two forum clauses the judge was considering, or whether the judge had actually found that Gorenstein agreed to the Ad Terms.

Hyperlinked terms required closer analysis

The Ad Terms contained a hyperlink to the Commercial Terms in paragraph 14, dealing with another subject. Paragraph 17, which directed disputes to the Commercial Terms, had no hyperlink.

The appeal court pointed to Supreme Court guidance on standard-form internet contracts: access to a clause electronically should not be more difficult than accessing its paper equivalent. Those considerations were relevant if the lower court was relying on the Commercial Terms, but had not been addressed.

The outcome therefore did not establish that Meta’s clauses were invalid, or that Gorenstein was entitled to damages. It dismissed this appeal for lack of Federal Court jurisdiction while identifying unresolved problems in the reasoning used to enforce the contractual forum provisions.