The Canadian Human Rights Tribunal has dismissed a pregnancy-discrimination complaint against Staff of the Non-Public Funds, Canadian Forces, finding that workplace setbacks were established but the evidence did not connect them to sex or pregnancy.

In Smith v. Staff of the Non-Public Funds, Canadian Forces, 2026 CHRT 108, tribunal member John Hutchings rejected allegations concerning attendance instructions, extended probation and an unsuccessful job application. He also declined to infer discrimination from interview records that the employer acknowledged it should have preserved.

The October 6 decision distinguishes adverse treatment from discrimination under the Canadian Human Rights Act. Keri-Lynn Smith proved that she had a protected characteristic and experienced adverse effects. She did not establish, on a balance of probabilities, that sex or pregnancy was a factor in those effects. The tribunal therefore did not reach justification or remedy.

Attendance concerns and disputed instructions

Smith worked as a human resources assistant. She said managers restricted bathroom use to scheduled breaks and required her to log it in Microsoft Outlook. The employer denied imposing those requirements, saying its instructions concerned ordinary leave and attendance policies.

Hutchings found that managers had told Smith she could use the bathroom at any time, without counting it toward breaks or lunch. Smith acknowledged that no one explicitly directed her to restrict or log bathroom use. She instead understood broader instructions about managing her time to mean that she had to account for every absence from her desk to overcome negative perceptions.

The tribunal accepted that Smith strongly believed this, but found the inference unreasonable in light of management's express guidance. It identified a communication breakdown without finding that sex or pregnancy contributed to it. The decision did not endorse the employer's general feedback practices or decide whether its performance concerns were justified.

A trainer's comments that Smith appeared disengaged, including an observation about slouching, did not change the result. Hutchings acknowledged that assumptions about posture can unfairly characterize pregnant workers. But the trainer was not Smith's manager, did not provide her performance feedback, and her comments aligned with other concerns about initiative. No one told Smith to improve her posture. The tribunal could not infer that posture associated with pregnancy drove management's response.

Managers also initially misapplied the sick-leave policy, requiring unpaid time before correcting the error and recording paid leave. Hutchings found no evidence connecting that mistake to sex or pregnancy. A colleague's criticism of the workplace and management treatment likewise did not establish the required connection.

Probation extensions and maternity leave

The employer extended Smith's probation twice. Managers described continuing performance concerns, and a new supervisor said she lacked a full opportunity to assess Smith's competencies. A further extension allowed assessment to pause during approved maternity leave and resume afterward.

Smith argued that other human resources assistants had not had probation extended. The tribunal found that the comparator she identified was not subject to performance concerns, making that employee's experience unhelpful in assessing her situation.

Hutchings did not decide who was right about the underlying performance disputes. He preferred management's evidence about the reason for the extensions: insufficient time to assess the concerns. Even a manager's unprofessional email remark did not establish a pregnancy connection.

The tribunal recognized that continued probation left Smith in a more precarious position. It nevertheless found that the extension also gave her a further opportunity to demonstrate competence and address concerns. Although maternity leave formed part of the factual setting, Hutchings distinguished the absence from work from the reason for that absence. On this record, the former explained the decision. That finding does not establish that every probation extension connected with maternity leave is lawful.

Hiring decision and lost interview records

Smith also applied for an administrative assistant role in the employer's Soldier On program. She disputed whether the successful candidate had sufficient experience to enter the competition. The interview panel's evidence was that he met the screening criteria and performed best in the interviews.

Hutchings found that disagreement about how to interpret the qualifications did not connect the outcome to Smith's sex or pregnancy. His task was not a general review of the staffing process. He accepted the panel's explanation for its choice.

The employer did not respond to Smith's request for an informal discussion about her result. Hutchings described that as unfortunate but found no reasonable basis to infer discrimination from it. Such a discussion could have addressed her interview performance; no witness described it as a process to challenge another candidate's selection.

The interview records presented a separate evidentiary issue. A labour relations officer failed to place a litigation hold on relevant documents after Smith complained. They were then destroyed under the ordinary two-year retention schedule. The tribunal agreed that the documents should have been preserved.

It nevertheless rejected the requested adverse inference. The evidence showed broader record-retention problems, rather than a problem confined to the successful candidate's file, and Hutchings accepted uncontradicted evidence that the omission was inadvertent. Inferring intentional destruction, or that the missing records would contradict the panel's testimony, would have been speculative.

Evidence of the successful candidate's later performance was not material to whether discrimination affected the hiring decision, so the tribunal made no findings about it.

Hearing fairness and the result

Hutchings confined his decision to evidence admitted at the hearing. He declined Smith's request to reopen the record to answer the employer's criticism of her colleague's credibility, finding that the criticism was an argument based on existing evidence that she could answer in reply. Reopening after both parties relied on the completed record would be unfair.

In any event, the colleague's credibility did not determine the case, and Hutchings made no finding against her credibility. The decisive questions concerned whether the proposed inferences about sex or pregnancy were reasonable. Finding that the necessary connection had not been proved across the allegations, he dismissed the complaint.

Read the full decision on CanLII.