A long-serving GardaWorld employee’s human rights complaint against the company and his union has been dismissed because he provided no evidence capable of establishing a disability that prevented him from wearing a mask.

The decision is Morrison v. GardaWorld Cash Services Canada Corporation and others (No. 2), 2026 BCHRT 218, issued by the British Columbia Human Rights Tribunal on October 16, 2026.

Shaun Morrison alleged that a workplace mask requirement discriminated against him and that Unifor Local 114 failed to support him. He said anxiety prevented mask-wearing. The complaint also named company managers and union representatives.

Tribunal member Jess Hadley dismissed the entire complaint under section 27(1)(c) of the Human Rights Code. Morrison did not respond to either dismissal application. The ruling was a preliminary assessment of the filed record, not a finding that his account of disability was dishonest.

GardaWorld imposed the requirement in September 2020. After Morrison refused to wear a mask and left work, the company placed him on unpaid leave. In correspondence with a union representative, he challenged masks as ineffective and an infringement of his rights.

The representative offered to pursue accommodation if Morrison had a documented condition preventing mask use. The emails did not identify such a condition. His grievance challenging the requirement and unpaid leave also did not mention disability. The employer denied the grievance, and the union did not advance it further.

The background record described Morrison remaining on leave after the requirement ended in May 2022. His employment ended after he did not return when asked in January 2023. Those events did not supply the missing evidence supporting the discrimination claim.

The respondents bore the burden of justifying dismissal. Hadley explained that the threshold for proceeding to a hearing is low, but requires some evidence beyond an allegation. A complainant must be able to establish a protected disability, adverse employment treatment and a connection between the two before the respondents must justify their conduct.

Anxiety can be a disability under the Code. Here, however, there was no medical note or other evidence showing a disability that prevented Morrison from wearing a mask. The tribunal could not speculate about evidence that might exist but had not been filed.

The absence of any disability explanation in the accommodation correspondence reinforced that conclusion. Hadley expressly left open the possibility that Morrison did have the claimed disability; the problem was proof on the record before her.

The tribunal did not decide the respondents’ alternative jurisdictional, procedural or prior-proceeding arguments. Nor did it issue a general endorsement of mask requirements or union grievance decisions. The entire complaint failed at the evidentiary threshold.