The Canadian Human Rights Tribunal has dismissed a complaint against the Bank of Nova Scotia after finding that repeated failures to provide required information, refusal to follow its orders and abusive communications made further proceedings untenable.

In Akisha McKenzie v. Bank of Nova Scotia, 2026 CHRT 117, tribunal member Jennifer Khurana concluded that the complainant’s conduct was vexatious and an abuse of process. The October 19 decision ended the complaint without deciding the merits of the underlying discrimination allegations.

The bank had initially moved to strike McKenzie’s statement of particulars, arguing that it was too vague and did not meet the tribunal’s procedural rules. In its reply, it also raised dismissal because of her repeated disregard of deadlines and orders. The Canadian Human Rights Commission was not participating in the proceeding.

Repeated extensions did not produce the required disclosure

The tribunal’s initial directions required McKenzie to provide particulars, disclosure, a witness list and summaries of anticipated testimony by August 14, 2026. After she missed that deadline, it repeatedly followed up, set further dates and warned about the consequences of noncompliance.

McKenzie said she had already sent her statement after an early case-management call. The tribunal told her it still lacked the required materials. She eventually filed a redacted statement on September 14, but did not provide the required document and witness information.

She alleged that evidence had disappeared or been destroyed and said she would present her evidence at the hearing instead. Two days later, she referred to numbered recordings, items of evidence and witnesses, but did not explain what the numbers identified or provide disclosure to the bank.

McKenzie opposed striking the statement or dismissing her complaint. She maintained that the alleged destruction of evidence justified her position, disputed that she was refusing to comply and accused the bank and tribunal process of unfairness. Khurana found the allegations of impropriety unsubstantiated; the ruling did not establish that the bank had destroyed evidence.

The bank lacked the information needed to answer the case

Khurana agreed that the statement failed to give the bank sufficient material facts to understand and fairly respond to the complaint. Among other deficiencies, it did not explain the connection between the alleged discriminatory practices and prohibited grounds of discrimination or identify the remedies sought.

McKenzie also failed to identify intended witnesses and summarize their evidence, list relevant documents or provide copies to the bank. An unexplained numbered list did not satisfy those obligations. Her position remained that disclosure would wait until the hearing.

The tribunal separately addressed her communications. It found that she had made offensive comments and unsupported allegations against the bank, the commission and the tribunal. A September 24 direction ordered her to stop, explained the requirement of civility and expressly warned that continued failure to respect tribunal orders could lead to dismissal.

Khurana found that the inflammatory comments continued despite that warning. McKenzie also persisted in seeking a decision in her favour while rejecting the procedural requirements for advancing the case.

Further directions would serve no purpose

Rules 9 and 10 permit dismissal for noncompliance, vexatious conduct or abuse of process. Khurana characterized dismissal as an exceptional and serious response, but found no value in issuing yet another order when McKenzie had repeatedly refused to comply and gave no indication that she intended to change course.

The tribunal rejected the suggestion that the problem could be resolved simply by providing more assistance to a self-represented litigant. An early case-management call had explained the process, and repeated follow-ups had given McKenzie opportunities to meet its requirements.

Khurana emphasized that flexibility has limits. Repeated deadlines, correspondence and follow-ups consume resources that could be used for other parties waiting to be heard. Allowing the conduct to continue would undermine the proper use of the human rights process.

The complaint was dismissed. The disposition rested on the procedural failures and abuse of process, rather than a finding that the bank had or had not discriminated.

Source: Akisha McKenzie v. Bank of Nova Scotia, 2026 CHRT 117.