
The Canadian Human Rights Tribunal has ordered the Taku River Tlingit First Nation to stop applying an overbroad policy that restricted a member’s participation in community life after she filed a human rights complaint. It awarded Susan Carlick $7,000 plus interest for retaliation, while rejecting her separate claim that her consulting contract was terminated because of her family status.
In Carlick v. Taku River Tlingit First Nation, 2026 CHRT 118, tribunal member Jo-Anne Pickel found that the First Nation had legitimate reasons to protect confidential information in litigation. But its Adverse Party Policy went too far, and the way representatives applied it to Carlick was retaliatory.
The October 20 decision requires changes before an amended or replacement policy can be introduced, training for representatives and a protocol for Carlick’s safe, retaliation-free participation. It does not establish that compensation has been paid or reforms implemented.
The termination claim lacked a link to family status
Carlick, a member of the First Nation and its Wolf Clan, held a consulting contract involving land stewardship and protection. The contract was terminated without cause in November 2022, following a contentious Joint Clan Meeting and disputes over her interactions with staff.
She alleged that she was treated adversely because she belonged to the Carlick family rather than the Jack family. She also advanced arguments based on her role as a mother and grandmother advocating for family members.
Pickel accepted that membership in the Carlick family was protected by the ground of family status. She also recognized that family relationships must be understood in their cultural context and may extend beyond narrow, Eurocentric conceptions.
However, she rejected an interpretation that would extend family status to general caregiving or advocacy for an adult child on the facts presented. Those actions were not shown to have the immutable characteristics or engage the legal responsibilities discussed in the relevant appellate authorities. Even if that broader characterization were accepted, the required connection to the termination was missing.
The tribunal had serious credibility concerns about two senior representatives’ assertions that they had played no role in the termination. Correspondence and the timing of an email sent shortly before the termination undermined their efforts to distance themselves. But those concerns did not themselves prove discrimination: Carlick still had to connect the decision to a prohibited ground.
The evidence did not show that the tense community meeting divided along family or clan lines. Members of Carlick’s own family supported the chair, and her clan leader asked her to leave. Other Carlick family members remained employed by the First Nation. Nor did evidence that the First Nation knew about her caregiving responsibilities establish that those responsibilities caused the termination. The family-status complaint failed.
Applying the policy amounted to retaliation
Carlick filed her discrimination complaint in February 2023. The First Nation adopted the Adverse Party Policy the following month and formally received her complaint in July.
The policy covered people involved in litigation or tribunal proceedings against the First Nation or its companies, alongside other categories of adverse parties. It restricted attendance at many meetings, access to records and participation in positions and committees. Joint Clan Meetings and Clan Meetings were excepted from its general restriction on attending First Nation meetings; other attendance could require prior written consent.
The tribunal did not find sufficient evidence that the policy was developed because of Carlick’s complaint. The record supported the explanation that it formed part of a broader set of governance and risk-management measures. But the absence of proof about its creation did not defeat the separate allegation concerning its application.
Carlick continued attending meetings and was not physically forced out. Nevertheless, representatives read the policy aloud and singled her out by name in efforts to make her leave. Pickel found that this was negative treatment linked to her complaint. Proof of an intention to retaliate was not required.
The First Nation argued that Carlick had not followed the process for seeking permission to attend. Pickel rejected that explanation. Without the policy, Carlick would not have needed permission; requiring approval from the very entity she had complained against reinforced the adverse treatment.
Protecting confidential or privileged information that could give an opposing litigant an advantage was legitimate. The problem was the policy’s breadth: it constrained community participation beyond meetings or committees where such information would be disclosed. Its application also portrayed human rights complainants as having done something wrong and risked discouraging others from asserting their rights.
Pickel considered the First Nation’s legal traditions and self-government interests, but concluded that they did not displace its obligations under the Canadian Human Rights Act. The findings recognized the legitimate protective purpose while addressing the policy’s retaliatory effects.
Compensation and policy reforms ordered
Carlick sought the maximum $20,000 for pain and suffering and a further $20,000 in special compensation. The tribunal instead awarded $5,000 for distress, isolation and interference with community governance participation caused by the policy. It distinguished those injuries from distress over losing the consulting contract, for which discrimination had not been proven.
A further $2,000 reflected reckless conduct. Pickel did not find wilful retaliation, but found that the First Nation had considered whether the policy complied with its constitution without similarly addressing the Act’s protection against retaliation. No lost-wage award was made because the termination complaint failed.
The $7,000 must be paid within 30 days of the decision, with simple interest at a rate equivalent to the Bank of Canada bank rate from July 10, 2023, until payment.
The First Nation must immediately stop applying the policy in its present form, including to Carlick. Its representatives must not criticize or stigmatize her for bringing human rights complaints.
Before introducing an amended or replacement policy, it must consult the Canadian Human Rights Commission, eliminate the retaliatory effects and tailor the policy to its legitimate purpose. All representatives must be trained to apply it consistently with the Act’s retaliation protections before it takes effect.
Within 30 days, the First Nation must also develop, in consultation with the commission, an agreed protocol for Carlick’s safe and retaliation-free participation in meetings, governance and events. Pickel left open the possibility of a restorative or healing process, but did not compel one.
The tribunal declined to order a public clarification or apology, noting that it lacked authority to compel an apology. It also rejected more detailed governance and social-service remedies that did not flow from the proven retaliation.
Source: Carlick v. Taku River Tlingit First Nation, 2026 CHRT 118.



