
Contractual security differed from statutory liens in allocating $151,000 from three trailer sales.
On October 28, 2026, in 2026 MBKB 149, Manitoba Court of King’s Bench Justice McCarthy held that Proud Transport's service agreement could not displace ATB Financial's earlier perfected security interest. Its common-law lien argument also failed beyond qualifying repairs: ordinary storage did not enhance the trailers' value.
But Manitoba's Warehousemen's Liens Act created a separate storage lien with priority under section 32 of the Personal Property Security Act. The trailers had been deposited by their owner, so the statutory notice requirement for deposits without owner authority did not apply.
Proud Transport was awarded $16,235 for repairs and maintenance, a priority ATB conceded. Its storage lien covered lawful charges relating to these three trailers, not every debt owed by the customer.
The court declined to adopt the agreement's $250 daily default rate without independent proof. If lawful storage charges cannot be agreed, further evidence and a hearing are required. ATB receives the remaining proceeds; accrued interest is apportioned and costs remain unresolved.



