
A Vancouver landlord must pay a former tenant $5,000 for discriminatory remarks that undermined his sense of safety at home, the British Columbia Human Rights Tribunal has ruled.
The decision is Hortua v. Winkler, 2026 BCHRT 227, issued by the British Columbia Human Rights Tribunal on 2026-11-03.
After a two-day hearing, tribunal member Robin Dean found that George Winkler discriminated against Robert Alexander Hortua in tenancy because of race and place of origin. Dean also ordered Winkler to stop and refrain from similar discrimination, but declined to require training.
The November 2021 encounter occurred while Hortua was disputing an eviction notice from the Columbia Hotel. The building was being prepared for sale, services had been reduced and Hortua approached Winkler about the broken elevator and lack of heat. A recording captured their conversation.
Winkler told Hortua to return to Mexico, although he knew the tenant came from Colombia, and disparaged his English. Dean found that the remarks conveyed that Hortua did not belong in the building or Canada and invoked a stereotype treating Latin American origins as interchangeable.
Winkler did not deny making the remarks. He characterized them as humour and pointed to his own experience as an immigrant and his efforts to house international students. Dean rejected the claim that the recording conveyed a joke or positive message. In any event, discriminatory intent was not required: the effect on the tenant was central.
A shared immigrant background did not erase the parties’ different circumstances or the landlord’s power over housing. Hortua was already vulnerable because his tenancy was threatened, and he was asking about repairs only the landlord could arrange. There was no apology.
The tribunal explained that a single incident can violate the Code when its seriousness, the relationship, surrounding circumstances and discriminatory impact justify intervention. This was not simply an unpleasant exchange between equals. Hortua felt unsafe and secured a new lease ten days later.
Hortua sought $20,000 for injury to dignity. Dean awarded $5,000, taking account of the serious impact of discrimination at home while distinguishing the brief encounter from repeated or more enduring mistreatment in higher-award cases. The tenancy was already ending for independent reasons, making it difficult to attribute all of Hortua’s insecurity to the discriminatory remarks.
The housing power imbalance and the tenant’s vulnerability justified more than an award involving workplace peers. Older awards also reflected the lower amounts historically ordered by the tribunal. The tribunal also rejected the landlord’s argument that no compensation should be ordered: the evidence showed real emotional harm, not merely a technical violation.
A separate $12,000 tenancy settlement had been divided between Hortua and his partner. Hortua’s $6,000 share did not displace the human rights award because it resolved an unrelated tenancy dispute and was not paid to address the effects of discrimination.
Dean declined mandatory human rights training because there was no evidence of a systemic practice or pattern. She considered the reasons and cease-and-refrain order sufficient to explain the landlord’s obligations and prevent recurrence.



