
The B.C. Human Rights Tribunal dismissed a grocery-store mask complaint because the store was reasonably certain to establish that the customer’s conduct had thwarted accommodation discussions.
In Girard v. Clace Holdings Ltd., 2026 BCHRT 230, issued November 4, Martin Girard alleged disability discrimination after being denied maskless shopping in January 2022.
The tribunal accepted that offering only online shopping would not have accommodated his circumstances. But the store appeared willing to explore alternatives, including curbside shopping. The evidence instead indicated that Girard focused on challenging the mask policy and insisted on entering without a mask.
Accommodation requires cooperation, not a customer’s preferred solution. The tribunal considered the store reasonably certain to establish that its policy served health and safety, was adopted in good faith and that its accommodation obligation ended when the dialogue was thwarted.
The complaint was dismissed under section 27(1)(c) of the Human Rights Code. This was a preliminary assessment of prospects, not factual findings after a hearing. Nor did the tribunal decide whether the policy precisely matched public-health orders.



