
Crown loses appeal of enhanced costs awarded to Marine Atlantic
A 60% legal-fee award survived scrutiny over delayed concessions and last-minute affidavit evidence in the ferry operator’s tax appeals.
Section
Civil procedure, court process, pleadings, motions, evidence, remedies and appellate procedure across Canada.
255 stories
A 60% legal-fee award survived scrutiny over delayed concessions and last-minute affidavit evidence in the ferry operator’s tax appeals.

The court upheld the quashing of a reassessment appeal and rejected a challenge to the evidence about an earlier assessment.

The judge found neither admissible nor credible evidence requiring a trial and ordered substantial-indemnity costs, with the amount left open.

Detailed evidence of two businesses’ dependence on loading docks supported temporary protection, while competing lease interpretations remained for trial.

A 6–3 ruling clarifies cause of action estoppel and its narrow fairness exception after a Newfoundland and Labrador mortgage accounting.

Definity wins mileage appeal on the evidence, without establishing a universal rate for treatment-related travel.

Evidence of a lifetime gift defeated the children’s appeal; the ruling did not create an automatic inheritance right for common-law partners.

Claims against the will-drafting lawyer and related defendants were dismissed, but the family’s challenge to the later will’s validity was left for trial.

The appeal concerned who would present the request, with the broader representation application left for a later hearing.

The court upheld the provincial recovery order and rejected a new limitation defence, while keeping the failed federal preference claim separate.

Federal Court of Appeal says good-faith and honour-of-the-Crown allegations require evidence; the ruling does not compel a land or mineral sale.

A Manitoba judge discharged the landowner’s injunction after expropriation and weighed the protest’s public-interest dimension against the owner’s earlier court success.

Shared employment terms and financial arrangements outweighed the benefit of a separate summary debt proceeding.

The generating-station exemption did not cover local poles and power lines, but the subcontractor’s final entitlement remains for trial.

Judicial review focused on the record supporting the breath-test suspension, not an assessment conducted months later.

Public use established goodwill before a rival festival; the court rejected a separate substitution claim and awarded $71,730.31 in costs.

Crown receives tariff costs, not 45 per cent of solicitor-client costs, after succeeding on a Part IV tax question.

Riddle v. ivari confirms that proof of survival abroad can overturn a Quebec declaration of death, while warning that failure to notify the missing person is a serious procedural…


Reliable copies can complete the Dawson City exchange, the court rules, while rejecting a blanket originals-only requirement.