
Sudbury judge rejects bid to stay charges over delay in joint jury trial
Ashawn Trench was ready for February trial dates that his co-accused’s lawyer could not make. The judge explained why the Crown could keep the two cases together.
Section
Court decisions, disputes and legal developments filed under Crime.
116 stories
Ashawn Trench was ready for February trial dates that his co-accused’s lawyer could not make. The judge explained why the Crown could keep the two cases together.

The appeal failed on both dangerous and impaired driving. An acquittal on a separate charge based on blood-alcohol concentration did not displace the evidence of impaired ability…

The court accepts a joint recommendation, emphasizing intimate partner violence, high moral responsibility and the limits of rehabilitation as a mitigating consideration.

The unanimous ruling adopts the territorial appeal majority’s reasons on a fatal truck incident in Yellowknife.

The court balanced denunciation and deterrence with Indigenous background factors, finding supervised reintegration necessary to protect the community from repeated violence.

A trial judge combined evidence from two evenings. The appeal court explained why the error undermined both convictions and why the charges called for different remedies.

N.L. appeal judge found a woman could finish her ten-month sentence before her appeal was heard, while treating misconduct allegations as unproven.

Sentence appeal permission was also refused.

The judge could consider the accused’s command of English, the interpreters’ courtroom experience and how well they communicated with him. The panel also reviewed the…

The panel accepted that Donald Burnett could not afford counsel but found his proposed sentence appeal lacked sufficient merit to justify public funding.

Jurors needed guidance on when observations can help establish age and how to avoid stereotypes, the Court of Appeal ruled in setting aside a sexual interference conviction.

Three prison-assault appeals failed after the court distinguished knowing the Crown’s case from obtaining advance rulings on possible defences and applied the Supreme Court’s…

The court rejects the Crown’s challenge to a release plan involving house arrest, GPS monitoring and financial security, without deciding guilt or extradition.

A 5–4 decision says a momentary lapse can meet the dangerous-driving fault threshold, with four judges finding no basis to overturn the acquittals.

The appeal panel found the judge acted fairly when he warned the accused about repeated interruptions and asked the prosecutor to explain the warning to the complainant.

Arthur Cook’s aggravated-assault conviction and 24-month custodial sentence stand after the court upheld the trial judge’s assessment of surveillance footage and the force used.

The appeal court rejected a categorical approach to firearms sentencing, finding that the young first offender’s restrictive conditional sentence was not demonstrably unfit.

The unanimous ruling distinguished relevant commercial evidence from stereotypes and considered the legislation applicable before the 2026 amendments.

The court rejected challenges to the assessment of the complainant’s testimony and found that proposed new evidence was too uncertain to justify reopening the case.

A partial video, disputed memories and a surprise attack left reasonable doubt, although bringing a knife and repeatedly using it weighed against the accused.