
Section
Crime
Court decisions, disputes and legal developments filed under Crime.
116 stories










Supreme Court upholds Bharwani murder conviction, clarifies fitness to stand trial
Judges agreed on a reality-based capacity standard but split over fresh psychiatric evidence and whether a new trial was needed.

Supreme Court sets proof standard for adult youth sentences, reduces I.M.’s life term
The Crown must prove adult-like developmental maturity beyond a reasonable doubt; the Court imposed a maximum youth sentence and remitted additional custody-credit questions.

Supreme Court upholds S.B.’s adult sentence despite error in maturity test
The Court found that the evidence met the stricter standard and rejected challenges to the treatment of social context, accountability and conduct in custody.


Supreme Court upholds pandemic judge-alone murder trial, returns remaining appeal grounds
All seven judges set aside the new-trial order in Varennes, but split over Charter remedies and prosecutorial discretion and refused to end the proceedings.

Supreme Court orders new Kinamore trial, extends sexual-history screening to sexual inactivity
The unanimous ruling required screening of sexual inactivity evidence and clarified the process for Crown applications.

Supreme Court acquits Tammy Bouvette after disclosure failure tainted guilty plea
All nine judges agreed on acquittal, but divided over how appeal courts should remedy miscarriages of justice when the record could still support a conviction.

Supreme Court awards J.W. extra custody credit, sets limits on treatment-based sentencing
The unanimous ruling upheld a nine-year term but found that delays linked to mental illness did not justify denying enhanced credit for psychiatric detention.

Supreme Court restores Sheppard’s six-year sentence, clarifies sentencing for historical offences
Modern sentencing principles apply within the historical statutory maximum, the unanimous court held in reasons explaining its earlier order to return to custody.
