
Supreme Court rejects Golden Oaks investors’ defences to repayment of unlawful returns
Ponzi-scheme appeal addresses limitation periods, set-off, referral commissions and preferential payments, with separate reasons on the route to the result.
Section
Court decisions, disputes and legal developments filed under Ontario.
401 stories

Ponzi-scheme appeal addresses limitation periods, set-off, referral commissions and preferential payments, with separate reasons on the route to the result.

Solvency did not defeat fraudulent-intent findings, and the corporate-attribution rules could not shield asset stripping from the statutory recovery remedy.



The unanimous decision requires honourable compensation for past breaches while preserving constrained Crown discretion over annuity increases.


The Court left a privacy grievance decision set aside after a principal read and photographed teachers’ private notes, while dividing on judicial review.




The majority held that a contractor accepted the risk of untested soil. A dissent would have preserved the statutory obligation to supply the agreed description.

A divided Court found the jury properly instructed on causation, while confirming that a fellow attacker’s act can sometimes break the chain of legal responsibility.





A unanimous court sent Yatar’s limitation dispute back to the tribunal, holding that a law-only appeal did not foreclose review of factual and mixed questions.

The court set aside the CBC disclosure order, while separate reasons disputed the standard for reviewing the privacy commissioner’s decision.
