
Unsecured creditors can invoke defence to payroll deemed-trust recovery
Federal Court of Appeal distinguishes innocent recipients of sale proceeds from creditor priority before distribution.
Section
Court decisions, disputes and legal developments filed under Tax.
72 stories
Federal Court of Appeal distinguishes innocent recipients of sale proceeds from creditor priority before distribution.

Federal appeal court says a downward adjustment requires the minister’s approval, even if the taxpayer disputes the arm’s-length price.









All seven judges dismissed the appeal, with different reasons on jurisdiction and a shared finding that the requested declarations had no practical utility.

A 4–3 decision keeps the minister’s discretionary refusal separate from a Tax Court assessment appeal; the dissent favoured resolving the challenge within that appeal.