
Supreme Court confirms Charter privacy rights for Ontario public school teachers
The Court left a privacy grievance decision set aside after a principal read and photographed teachers’ private notes, while dividing on judicial review.
Section
Court decisions, disputes and legal developments filed under Supreme Court.
97 stories
The Court left a privacy grievance decision set aside after a principal read and photographed teachers’ private notes, while dividing on judicial review.

The majority held that a contractor accepted the risk of untested soil. A dissent would have preserved the statutory obligation to supply the agreed description.

The Court divided over reconsidering excluded evidence but agreed that targeted publication restrictions could protect the complainant on appeal.

A divided Court found the jury properly instructed on causation, while confirming that a fellow attacker’s act can sometimes break the chain of legal responsibility.

The unanimous court restored a valuation order reflecting existing land-use restrictions, while leaving the Lynch family’s established entitlement to compensation intact.

The divided Court placed the burden on the Crown to show that a missed notice did not deprive a bilingual accused of an informed choice of trial language.

The unanimous result preserves constitutional bargaining rights while dividing judges over the test for access to legislative protection.

Treaty rights were enforceable before 1982, so constitutional protection did not revive the lawsuit. A declaration nevertheless confirmed Canada’s 162.5-square-mile shortfall.

A 7–2 ruling attributes third-party fraud to a bank that knowingly participated, while dividing judges over the effect of Greek judgments.

The majority applied the Charter but found section 25 protected land-based leadership; separate opinions divided over both constitutional questions.

A unanimous court sent Yatar’s limitation dispute back to the tribunal, holding that a law-only appeal did not foreclose review of factual and mixed questions.

The Court preserved established appellate standards for witness assessments, while a separate concurrence proposed broader review of unreasonable generalizations.

A 5–4 majority recognized privacy in the digital link to a user’s online activity and ordered a new trial; the dissent disputed the breadth of the ruling on this evidence.

The Court upheld the trial judge’s findings on murder intent and self-defence, and explained why Crown challenges to acquittals must identify a genuine legal error.

The unanimous ruling sustains national standards and the federal force of qualifying Indigenous laws while leaving the constitutional scope of self-government open.

The court set aside the CBC disclosure order, while separate reasons disputed the standard for reviewing the privacy commissioner’s decision.

All 31 accused could raise the alleged abuse of process, but the Court required individual analysis of counsel-access delays and consideration of lesser remedies.