
Ontario appeal court quashes appeals over access to disputed property
An exclusive-possession order and a 100-metre restriction left ownership for trial. An appeal of either case management order required leave from the Divisional Court.
Section
Civil lawsuits and court proceedings across Canada, including liability, damages, contracts, property and estate disputes, class actions, settlements and enforcement.
417 stories
An exclusive-possession order and a 100-metre restriction left ownership for trial. An appeal of either case management order required leave from the Divisional Court.

William Waters kept notes on properties bought with his money. The appeal court said the trial judge overlooked what those records could reveal about whether he intended gifts.

The judge heard the request despite a gap in the son’s pleadings. His account of his father’s declining health fell short of the evidence needed to register a claim against the…

Avonlea accepted shares after a merger missed its deadline. The court ordered the investor to keep its side of the bargain and end a separate oppression petition.

The defendants argued that their motion had succeeded because the plaintiffs had to explain the delay. The judge found that the choice of motion added expense and left the case on…

The defendant argued that fraud allegations and simplified procedure demanded quicker progress. The judge applied a five-year benchmark and also rejected dismissal over disputed…

The panel upheld a refusal of leave to appeal, finding the former tenants had not justified an exceptional injunction while pursuing more than $6 million in damages.

A $20,200 refund for excess contributions did not exempt the owner from its proportionate share of the syndicate’s professional fees.

Canada sought to rule out a declaration of ownership before the remedies trial. The judge found that evidence about reconciliation could still affect the outcome.

The developer failed to restore a $3.55-million reduction. It can bring a fresh motion with evidence showing which subcontractors had liens when they were paid.

A letter of intent and years spent refurbishing the Woolwich inn gave its operators no right to stay after the owners ended their commercial lease.

The claim lacked an independent basis for damages and repeated a challenge already dismissed for delay. The court did not decide the proposed CERB and CRB income interpretation.

The court upheld the available defences and separately found that protecting public debate outweighed the demonstrated harm. Full-indemnity costs remain subject to submissions.

The successful defendant received $30,000 in costs and $10,024.49 in disbursements after the court assessed the fee request and scrutinized supporting expense records.

Lone Star failed to explain how it missed a claim delivered to its registered address. The court clarified when a judge can let a defendant back into a case before default…

Ontario’s Divisional Court upheld the judgment after an Ottawa homeowner disputed the size of his bill but repeatedly acknowledged that he owed money.

Dmytro Sochnyev knew from the outset that his appeal belonged in the Divisional Court. The panel quashed it and awarded the lawyers’ insurer $7,000 in costs.

A judge weighing security for appeal costs can consider a case’s weakness without deciding that it is bound to fail. The court explained how the litigant’s means fit into that…

A Toronto investment property sold while two former partners disputed who owned it. The appeal court’s declaration determines who is entitled to the sale proceeds.

The judge reduced both companies’ costs requests, finding that the work billed exceeded what the unsuccessful broker could reasonably expect to pay.