
FCA upholds TFSA advantage tax and minister’s relief power
The court rejected a due-diligence defence and found that Parliament, not the minister, had set the tax and its rate.
Section
Federal Court of Appeal decisions and developments
61 stories
The court rejected a due-diligence defence and found that Parliament, not the minister, had set the tax and its rate.

Federal Court of Appeal preserves removal of some listed services after correcting the visual-dominance analysis; Therme has sought Supreme Court leave.

Federal Court of Appeal upholds the 2011 reassessment in Chad, distinguishing legally effective trades from an activity pursued for profit.

Federal Court of Appeal says good-faith and honour-of-the-Crown allegations require evidence; the ruling does not compel a land or mineral sale.

The court rejected an added complicity requirement and found the minister’s reasons responsive to the daughters’ arguments.

Federal appeal court overturns duty relief for Medline gloves and distinguishes benefits to surgeons from enhancements to scalpels.

Federal appeal court defers to expert-based claim construction and leaves Simplot’s non-infringement finding intact.

Public use established goodwill before a rival festival; the court rejected a separate substitution claim and awarded $71,730.31 in costs.

Crown receives tariff costs, not 45 per cent of solicitor-client costs, after succeeding on a Part IV tax question.

A successful challenge to deficient record-keeping did not establish that replacement ship masters were unqualified, appeal court says.

Court requires meaningful scrutiny of investigative production orders while rejecting cost alone as a Charter-based limit.

Court found no live controversy resolved by the declarations and did not decide whether the publisher’s paywall was a protection measure.

Federal appeal court ordered delayed workplace reviews but declined to dictate all-inclusive service standards; Supreme Court granted leave to appeal.

Appeal court finds the broadcasting standstill freezes distribution conditions despite contractual powers to change them.

Swiss-origin certification did not resolve confusion with Hershey’s marks; online survey admissibility remains case-specific.

Railway had requested a decision without a hearing and never asked to answer the employee’s reply, appeal court says.

Federal Court of Appeal applies GAAR to DAC’s British Virgin Islands continuance; company has sought Supreme Court leave.

Deemed acquisition before a partnership existed carried a notional tax year for the limited purpose of the available-for-use rules.

Nearly $14 million in disputed input tax credits remained disallowed because the expenses supported exempt financial services.

Federal Court of Appeal distinguishes innocent recipients of sale proceeds from creditor priority before distribution.